Please give a warm welcome to this week's guest in the spotlight, Gill Stewart. When Gill asked if I would be interested in a blog post on writing cross genre, my answer was a resounding 'yes'. Writing across genres has always interested me and having recently published the third in a YA mystery/romance, Gill is a bit of an expert.
Over to you, Gill.
This month my third Young Adult mystery/romance, No More Lies,
was published. This is the final book in a trilogy following the story of
George and Finn’s growing romance, but in each book there is always at least
one mystery to be solved. I didn’t set out particularly to write romance or mystery, and definitely not both! It’s
just that the first book developed that way and the others naturally followed
on.
By the time I came to writing Young Adult, I was already
published in two genres – sweet romance (as Gillian Villiers) and women’s
contemporary fiction (as Gilly Stewart). So what made me venture into this new
arena? Firstly it was because I’ve always loved reading YA. And when I think
back to some of the favourites, they often feature either romance or some kind
of mystery to be solved – or both. Think Anne
Of The Island crossed with Harry
Potter and the Prisoner of Azkeban; that would pretty much be my perfect
book!
So, although these thoughts weren’t conscious, they must
have been there at the back of my mind. Music and Lies started first and
foremost with the setting: a rather wild music festival. I’d found myself at an
off-beat music festival as the (unwilling) responsible adult for 3
thirteen-year-old boys. The lack of willingness was on both sides – I wasn’t
sure I wanted to be there and the boys definitely didn’t want me around! We came to an
uneasy truce where I sort-of kept them in sight and they pretended to ignore me
completely.
The festival was in the depths of a forest, with almost no
mobile signal, and the feel that a great deal of illicit substances were being
consumed. What would it be like, I wondered, if a girl a little older than
these boys found herself at such a festival, unsupervised? And the idea of
George going to the Forest Fest was born. The other characters gradually came
to life – Finn, the strange, reserved boy who George becomes more and more
attracted to. So it was going to be a romance! And then the knowledge that
there were crimes taking place, that both George and Finn were keen to solve,
although for different reasons. Ah, so this was going to be a mystery, too, was
it?
Once I had this template in mind, it was easy enough to
move on to the second book, Bright Lights and Lies. I definitely wanted
to continue developing the relationship between George and Finn and by moving
the story to a big city – Glasgow – I could incorporate the story of a sleazy
journalist, homeless people and George’s favourite band. For the final book, No More Lies, the location
changes again, this time to the Scottish Highlands, in winter. For once it
seems that things really will go smoothly for George and Finn, until Finn
learns the truth about his own past, and mysterious stray dogs begin to turn up
on the doorstep. Yes, we have another mystery waiting to be solved!
There are definitely some advantages to writing
cross-genre:
- As someone who occasionally struggles to have enough ‘plot’, I now had plenty!
- It was easy to vary the pace of the book by moving from one strand of the story to another.
- I had 2 hooks on which to hang the marketing: both romance and mystery.
But on the other hand there were definite disadvantages:
- I had to make sure that both strands were given sufficient prominence, but that neither overshadowed the other
- I had to make sure I didn’t ‘lose’ one of the threads at certain points
- The mysteries required a great deal of research
- How would I market this: as a romance or as a mystery?
Would I do this again? Yes! But next time I will Do More Advance Planning. As a typical
‘pantster’ writer, I was going into the mist and really not knowing what was
going to happen next. This meant that when I had reached the end I had to do a lot of editing. If I had planned
better I could have saved a lot of time.
Despite the challenges, I’ve loved delving into 2 genres
at once, and would definitely recommend it to anyone else who is looking for a
new challenge, and a bit of fun.
Find me at:
GILL-MARIE STEWART - https://www.facebook.com/pages/Gill-Marie-Stewart/1565665140343048
@paisleypiranhas
GILLY STEWART - https://www.facebook.com/GillyStewartWriter
@GillStewart2
Time to
tell the truth?
Finn
is not happy when dippy Aunt Lulu drags him off to spend Christmas on a
community farm in the Scottish Highlands. Things look up when his girlfriend
George joins them, though. Finn needs to start making some decisions about his
life, but when abandoned dogs turn up on the doorstep, and Aunt Lulu starts
revealing uncomfortable truths, it all gets a bit overwhelming …
George
can’t sort out what is going on with her and Finn, so she concentrates on
getting to the bottom of the mystery dogs. Impulsive and unpredictable as
always, her actions lead her and Finn into danger once again.
No more lies: it's time for
George and Finn to tell the truth about their feelings and move forward. But
will that be together or apart?
I can see that balancing the two elements and creating a single story rather than two halves must be difficult.
ReplyDeleteThanks for popping by Patsy. It is difficult - but interesting too!
DeleteMy own novel is romance/mystery and it was a challenge to balance the two.
DeleteIntriguing to learn about the issues with cross-genre fiction, though it sounds as fun to write as to read. Thank you, Gill and Wendy.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Tracy.
DeleteThanks Tracy!
DeleteReally enjoyed your post, Gill, and looking forward to catching up with this series as I love YA in between other reading. I'm a total panster too so can understand the difficulties sometimes! Funnily enough my latest release combines romance and suspense for the first time which is a slight departure. All the best with your trilogy - and your other genres!
ReplyDeleteI'm a total panster too, Rosemary - wish I wasn't.
DeleteThanks Rosemary. I think if you're a pantser it's sooo difficult to change!
DeleteThis is something I've never considered: that a story idea has to be slotted into a genre first. I tend to do it the other way round - which is probably where I'm going wrong!
ReplyDeleteI'm sure there's no 'right way' Julia - just 'our way' 😊
DeleteI agree, there is no right way. But agents and publishers are always looking for a marketing slot in which to put a book, so it's good to know where yours fits.
DeleteVery interesting to read how the two threads are combined, fun to write but hard work too!
ReplyDeleteThanks for your comment, Penny. I agree.
DeleteYes, it is fun! Thanks.
DeleteYou make writing cross genre sound so simple, Gill! I'm a fan of YA fiction, too. Think it's a great way to keep in touch with how young people view the world. Wishing you every success with the final novel in the series. : )
ReplyDeleteI'm ashamed to say I've never read any YA, Rae, but Gill's post has made me want to change that.
DeleteThanks Rae!
DeleteSo interesting to know, Gill, how the characters arrived with you and evolved. Love the idea of Anne of the Island crossed with HP and the Prisoner of Azkaban!
ReplyDeleteIt sounds fascinating doesn't it, Kate.
DeleteSo do I Kate. Now we need someone to write it!
DeleteA fascinating post, Gill. Thank you for sharing your experience and wishing you lots of success!! Thanks for hosting, Wendy. Hope you are well.
ReplyDeleteSo glad you found it interesting!
Delete